Barefoot Shoes Myths

Barefoot Shoes: Myths vs. Facts

Last Updated on September 10, 2023

BareTread is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.


In the world of footwear, barefoot shoes have sparked a revolution.

They’ve challenged traditional shoe design norms and introduced a new way of thinking about our feet’s interaction with the ground.

However, as with any revolutionary concept, barefoot shoes have been surrounded by a cloud of myths and misconceptions.

In this article, we’ll debunk some of the most common myths about barefoot shoes and shed light on the facts, backed by scientific evidence.

Myth #1: Barefoot Shoes are Only for the Athletic

One of the most common misconceptions about barefoot shoes is that they’re exclusively designed for athletes or those with a highly active lifestyle.

This couldn’t be further from the truth.

Barefoot shoes are for anyone and everyone who values natural movement, regardless of their level of physical activity.

From office workers who spend hours on their feet to avid hikers exploring rugged terrains, barefoot shoes can offer unique benefits.

Barefoot Shoes Office

They allow your feet to move naturally, promoting better balance and posture. They can also help strengthen the muscles in your feet, which are often underused when wearing traditional shoes.

Myth #2: Barefoot Shoes Lack Protection

At first glance, barefoot shoes might seem to offer little protection.

After all, they lack the thick soles and cushioning that we’ve come to associate with protective footwear.

However, this is another myth that needs debunking.

Barefoot shoes are designed to offer the right kind of protection – one that doesn’t compromise the foot’s natural movement.

They protect your feet from sharp objects and rough surfaces while allowing you to feel the ground beneath you.

Barefoot Protection

This enhanced ground feel can lead to improved balance and proprioception, which is your body’s sense of where it is in space.

While scientific studies on barefoot shoes are still emerging, preliminary research suggests that wearing minimalist shoes can lead to positive changes in foot mechanics and strength.

However, it’s important to note that transitioning to minimalist footwear should be a gradual process to allow your feet to adapt to the new shoes.

Myth #3: Barefoot Shoes are Uncomfortable

One of the most common myths about barefoot shoes is that they are uncomfortable.

While it’s true that they may feel different at first, this is largely due to the fact that they require a different way of walking and standing.

Traditional shoes often have elevated heels and cushioning that alter our natural gait, while barefoot shoes aim to mimic the natural movement of our feet.

When you first start wearing barefoot shoes, you might experience some discomfort as your feet adjust to the new footwear.

Barefoot Shoes AT FIRST

This is because your feet are used to the support and cushioning provided by traditional shoes.

However, this discomfort is typically temporary and decreases as your feet strengthen and adapt to the new way of walking.

In fact, a study found that strengthening the muscles of the ankle and foot can improve running mechanics and postural control.

This suggests that barefoot shoes, which require more muscle engagement than traditional shoes, could potentially enhance your foot strength and overall biomechanics over time.

Transitioning to Barefoot Shoes

If you’re considering making the switch to barefoot shoes, it’s important to start slowly. Here are some tips to help you transition:

  1. Start by wearing your barefoot shoes for short periods of time. This could be for a few hours each day, gradually increasing the duration as your feet adjust.
  2. Walk before you run. Before you start running or doing high-impact activities in your barefoot shoes, get used to walking in them first. This will help your feet and body adjust to the new movement patterns.
  3. Listen to your body. If you feel any pain or discomfort while wearing your barefoot shoes, it’s important to take a break. Overdoing it can lead to injuries.
  4. Consider foot strengthening exercises. Exercises that target the muscles in your feet can help prepare them for the demands of barefoot shoes.

Remember, everyone’s experience with barefoot shoes will be different. What works for one person might not work for another.

It’s important to find what works best for you and your feet.

Myth #4: Barefoot Shoes are Only for the “Perfect” Foot

Another common myth about barefoot shoes is that they’re only suitable for people with “perfect” feet.

This is far from the truth. In fact, barefoot shoes can be beneficial for a variety of foot types and conditions.

For instance, people with flat feet may find that barefoot shoes provide a more comfortable and natural fit than traditional shoes.

This is because barefoot footwear allows your feet to move and function as they naturally would in nature, which can help strengthen the muscles in your feet and potentially improve foot mechanics.

Plantar Fasciitis

Similarly, individuals with plantar fasciitis may find relief with barefoot shoes.

By promoting a more natural foot movement, barefoot shoes can help alleviate the strain on the plantar fascia, which is often a cause of pain for people with this condition.

However, it’s important to note that while barefoot shoes can be beneficial for some foot conditions, they may not be suitable for everyone.

Always consult with a healthcare professional before making significant changes to your footwear, especially if you have existing foot conditions.

Imagine your foot as a superhero.

Yes, you heard it right! Just like a superhero, your foot has certain characteristics and mechanics that can influence the world around it.

In this case, that world is your body, specifically your lower extremities.

Now, let’s bring some science into our superhero story.

There’s this cool study called “Foot characteristics and mechanics in individuals with knee osteoarthritis: systematic review and meta-analysis“. Sounds fancy, right? Well, it is!

This study found that our foot’s characteristics can affect several lower body conditions, including knee osteoarthritis.

Here’s the kicker: the study found that people with knee osteoarthritis often have a more pronated foot posture.

That’s like our superhero standing in a less-than-optimal superhero pose.

But here’s where barefoot shoes come in, like a trusty sidekick! They can help improve foot mechanics, potentially helping our foot superhero stand in a better, more beneficial pose. This could potentially have a positive effect on conditions like knee osteoarthritis.

So, just like every superhero needs a sidekick, your feet might just benefit from the sidekick powers of barefoot shoes!

Myth #5: Barefoot Shoes Will Break the Bank

While some barefoot shoes can be pricey, it’s not a rule.

Walking and Hiking Shoes
Xero Mesa Trail – Men’s

There are many affordable options available that offer the same benefits as their more expensive counterparts. Brands like Xero Shoes, Merrell, and Vivobarefoot offer a range of barefoot shoes at different price points, ensuring that there’s something for every budget.

When choosing a pair of barefoot shoes, it’s important to consider more than just the price.

Look at the materials used, the design of the shoe, and read reviews to ensure you’re getting a quality product. Remember, a higher price doesn’t always mean a better shoe.

For those on a budget, it’s worth noting that barefoot shoes tend to be more durable than traditional shoes.

This is because they’re designed to let your foot move naturally, reducing the wear and tear that can come from forcing your foot to move in a way it wasn’t designed to. So while the upfront cost might be higher, you could save money in the long run.

For more information on affordable barefoot shoes, check out our guide on Choosing the Right Pair.

Conclusion: Barefoot Shoes – More Than Just a Trend

Barefoot shoes are more than just a passing fad.

They’re a return to the way our feet were designed to move.

By debunking these common myths, we hope to shed some light on the benefits of barefoot shoes and encourage more people to give them a try.

Moving without pain after changing to barefoot shoes

Whether you’re a runner, a hiker, or just someone looking for a more natural way to move, barefoot shoes could be the answer.

They offer a range of benefits, from improved foot strength and balance to potential relief from foot pain.

And with a variety of styles and prices available, there’s a pair of barefoot shoes out there for everyone.

For more information on barefoot shoes, from how to choose the right pair to the science behind them, be sure to check out our other articles on BareTread.

Remember, everyone’s feet are different. What works for one person might not work for another. Always listen to your body and consult with a healthcare professional if you have any concerns. Happy barefooting!

Similar Posts